Transabdominal cervical cerclage: laparoscopy versus laparotomy.

Abstract

STUDY OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the obstetric outcome, surgical morbidity, and pre-abdominal cerclage characteristics of women undergoing transabdominal cerclage (TAC) via laparotomy or laparoscopy. DESIGN: Prospective cohort study (Canadian Task Force classification II-2). SETTING: University hospital. PATIENTS AND INTERVENTION: Between 2007 and 2014, 51 patients underwent laparoscopic abdominal cervical cerclage to treat cervical incompetence. These women were compared with a historical cohort of 18 patients who underwent the same procedure via laparotomy between 1995 and 2011. All of the women had a diagnosis of cervical incompetence based on previous obstetric history and/or a short or absent cervix. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The fetal survival rate postcerclage was 100% in the laparotomy group (n = 30 pregnancies) and 98% in the laparoscopy group (n = 54 pregnancies). There were no perioperative pregnancy losses in either group. The median gestation age was 36.9 weeks (range: 35.0-37.3) in the laparotomy group and 37.0 weeks (range: 34.7-38.0) in the laparoscopy group. Complications were recorded in 4 (22%) cases from the laparotomy group and 1 (2%) of the laparoscopies; however, the types of complications might not be comparable between groups. There were no conversions to laparotomy in the laparoscopy group. Pre-TAC median gestational age in the laparotomy group was 24.0 weeks (range: 20.0-25.1) with 19 (57.6%) previous pregnancies occurring after transvaginal cervical cerclage placement. The corresponding laparoscopy pre-TAC median gestational age was 22.0 weeks (range 19.0-34.0) with 40 (40%) previous pregnancies having a transvaginal cerclage. Before the TAC, women in the laparotomy group had lost 25 babies, and 63 babies were lost in the laparoscopy group. After TAC, these numbers were 0 and 1. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings show that transabdominal cervical cerclage placed laparoscopically appears to be as effective as TAC placed via laparotomy. Neither approach was associated with serious or long-term complications. Because of this finding, the approach depends on the surgical experience and expertise of the unit in conjunction with discussion with the patient.